Hey fellow eco-warriors! 
I’ve been diving deep into the world of natural paints for my latest home renovation project, and I’ve hit a bit of a crossroads. I’m trying to decide between using xanthan gum and guar gum as natural thickeners for my eco-friendly paint. Both seem promising, but I’m curious about your experiences and thoughts on which one might be the better choice for a sustainable paint project.
I’ve previously used Earth Pigments’ natural paint base, which worked wonders on my living room walls, but I’m looking to experiment a bit more with the consistency this time around. I’ve read that xanthan gum is great for creating a smooth, even texture, while guar gum is praised for its strong thickening properties and compatibility with a variety of surfaces. However, I’m also mindful of the environmental impact of sourcing these gums and how they perform in different climates and conditions.
Has anyone here tried both xanthan and guar gum in their natural paint recipes? How did they compare in terms of application, durability, and environmental footprint? Also, if you’ve worked with any specific brands or have tips on where to source these thickeners sustainably, I’d love to hear about it. Let’s share our knowledge and help each other make more informed, eco-conscious choices in our DIY projects!
Hey @EcoPainter88, great topic! I’ve experimented with both xanthan and guar gum in my natural paint projects. Xanthan gum definitely gives a smoother texture, which is perfect for walls. However, I found guar gum to be more versatile, especially when working on different surfaces like wood or metal. Both have their pros and cons, but if sustainability is your main concern, I’d recommend looking into the sourcing practices of the brands you’re considering. Some companies are more transparent about their environmental impact than others.
3 Likes
Thanks @GreenThumb99! That’s really helpful. Do you have any specific brands in mind that are transparent about their sourcing? I’m trying to make this project as eco-friendly as possible.
1 Like
I’ve only used guar gum so far, and it’s been great for thickening without compromising the paint’s natural properties. I got mine from EcoSupplies, and they have a pretty good environmental policy. Just a tip: make sure to mix it well to avoid clumps!
2 Likes
@NatureLover23, thanks for the tip! I’ll check out EcoSupplies. Did you notice any difference in how the paint dried or its durability when using guar gum?
1 Like
I’m all for experimenting with natural thickeners! Xanthan gum has been my go-to for a silky finish, but I’m intrigued by the versatility of guar gum mentioned by @GreenThumb99. Has anyone tried mixing both to get the best of both worlds?
4 Likes
@DIYQueen, that’s an interesting idea! Mixing both could potentially offer a balanced texture and thickening power. I’ll have to experiment with that. Thanks for the suggestion!
2 Likes
Just a quick note on climate impact - I’ve found that xanthan gum performs better in more humid conditions, while guar gum can be a bit finicky. Might be something to consider depending on where you live!
3 Likes
@SunnyDays, that’s a great point! I hadn’t considered the climate factor. I live in a pretty humid area, so xanthan gum might be the way to go for me. Thanks for the insight!
1 Like
I’ve been using xanthan gum for a while now in my eco-friendly paints, and I must say, the smoothness it adds is unbeatable. It’s especially great for indoor projects where you want that flawless finish. But yeah, sourcing is key. I always check if the brand has sustainable practices. It’s a bit pricier, but worth it for the quality and peace of mind.
Guar gum all the way for me! I’ve found it to be super versatile, especially when I’m working on different materials. It thickens really well, and I’ve noticed it holds up better in humid conditions compared to xanthan gum. Plus, it’s easier to find brands that are transparent about their environmental impact, which is a huge plus for me.
Interesting discussion! I’ve tried both, and honestly, it depends on the project. For walls, I lean towards xanthan gum for that smooth finish. But for furniture or outdoor projects, guar gum has been my go-to because of its durability. It’s all about experimenting and seeing what works best for your specific needs. Also, checking out local suppliers can sometimes lead you to more sustainable options than the big brands.
I’ve experimented with both xanthan and guar gum in my eco-friendly paints, and I gotta say, xanthan gum takes the cake for me. It blends so smoothly, and I’ve noticed it holds up better in humid conditions. I sourced mine from GreenCraft, and they’re pretty transparent about their sourcing. Just a heads-up, though, it can get a bit pricey, but I think it’s worth it for the quality.
Interesting take! I’ve been on the guar gum train for a while now, mainly because of how cost-effective it is. I found that it works best when I mix it with a bit of warm water before adding it to the paint. This trick has saved me from the dreaded clumps. I get mine from Nature’s Best, and they seem to have a solid commitment to sustainability. Have you tried mixing the two gums? I wonder if that could give the best of both worlds.
Mixing xanthan and guar gum sounds like a genius idea! I’ve been using xanthan gum for a while now, and while it does give that smooth finish, I’ve noticed it can sometimes make the paint a bit too runny in humid conditions. Maybe adding a bit of guar gum could help with that? Has anyone tried this combo in different weather conditions?
I’ve actually tried mixing both in a small batch for a test wall in my garage. The result was pretty interesting. The paint had a nice, thick consistency that was easy to apply, and it dried evenly without cracking. However, I did notice that it took a bit longer to dry compared to using just xanthan gum. Might be something to consider if you’re working on a tight schedule.
3 Likes