Comparing the durability of colors in lime wash vs other eco-friendly paints

Hey everyone! I’ve been diving deep into the world of eco-friendly paints for my latest home renovation project. I’m particularly fascinated by lime wash paints and how they compare to other natural paint options in terms of color durability. I’ve used Earthborn Claypaint in the past, which I loved for its breathability and low VOC content, but I’m curious about how lime wash holds up over time, especially in high-traffic areas.

I recently applied Bauwerk Lime Paint in a soft terracotta shade to my living room walls. The application was a dream, and the finish is stunning, but I’m wondering about its longevity. Has anyone else experimented with lime wash in spaces that see a lot of action? How do the colors fare against fading or wear compared to other eco-friendly paints like clay or milk paint?

Also, I’m considering trying lime wash on some exterior surfaces. Does anyone have experience with how it stands up to the elements? I’m all about reducing my environmental footprint, but I also want my home to look vibrant and welcoming for years to come. Would love to hear your thoughts and experiences!

I’ve been using Bauwerk Lime Paint for a couple of years now, both indoors and outdoors. In my experience, the color durability indoors is quite impressive, especially in areas with moderate traffic. However, outdoors, I’ve noticed some fading after a year or so, particularly in areas exposed to direct sunlight. It’s still my go-to for its eco-friendly properties, but I do touch-ups annually.

3 Likes

@GreenThumb88 Thanks for sharing your experience! It’s good to know that Bauwerk Lime Paint holds up well indoors. I’m a bit concerned about the outdoor fading you mentioned. Do you think applying a protective topcoat could help with that?

1 Like

@EcoPainterJane I haven’t tried a protective topcoat yet, but it’s an interesting idea. I’ll look into eco-friendly options and give it a try this spring. I’ll keep you posted on the results!

2 Likes

I’ve experimented with both Earthborn Claypaint and lime wash in my home. While I love the texture and depth of color that lime wash provides, I’ve found that Earthborn Claypaint tends to be more durable in high-traffic areas. That said, the aesthetic of lime wash is unmatched, so I use it in less trafficked spaces for that beautiful, soft finish.

4 Likes

@SunnyDaysAhead That’s a great strategy! I might consider using Earthborn Claypaint for the hallways and lime wash for the living room to get the best of both worlds. Thanks for the tip!

2 Likes

Has anyone tried mixing lime wash with other natural pigments to enhance color durability? I’m curious if that could be a solution for the fading issue, especially for outdoor applications.

1 Like

@DIYQueen That’s an intriguing idea! I haven’t tried mixing pigments yet, but it sounds like a fun experiment. If anyone has experience with this, I’d love to hear about the results.

1 Like

I just wanted to chime in and say how much I appreciate this discussion. It’s so refreshing to see a community focused on eco-friendly home improvements. I’m learning a lot and can’t wait to try some of these paints in my own home!

5 Likes

I’ve been using Bauwerk Lime Paint for a couple of years now, both indoors and outdoors. In my experience, the color durability indoors is quite impressive, especially in areas with moderate traffic. However, outdoors, I’ve noticed some fading after a year or so, particularly in areas exposed to direct sunlight. It’s still my go-to for its eco-friendly properties, but I do touch-ups annually.

2 Likes

Interesting to hear about the fading outdoors. I’ve been considering lime wash for my garden walls but was worried about maintenance. Maybe I’ll look into a more sheltered spot for it. Have you tried any protective coatings to extend the color life outside?

3 Likes

I haven’t tried protective coatings yet, but that’s a good idea. I wonder if there’s an eco-friendly option that wouldn’t negate the benefits of using lime wash in the first place. Does anyone have recommendations for natural sealants that work well with lime paint?

I’ve used beeswax as a natural sealant on lime wash before, and it does help with water resistance. However, it might alter the finish slightly, giving it a more matte look. It’s worth testing on a small area first to see if you like the effect.

That’s a great tip about beeswax. I’m all for natural solutions. On a different note, how does lime wash handle humidity indoors? I live in a pretty humid area and am curious if it would be a good fit for my bathroom.

3 Likes

Lime wash is actually great for humid environments because it’s breathable and helps regulate moisture. I used it in my bathroom, and it’s held up really well. Just make sure the walls are properly prepared before application to get the best results.

I’ve actually tried mixing lime wash with natural pigments for an outdoor mural. The colors did seem to hold up better against the sun, but it’s only been a year. I used a mix of ochre and lime wash, and so far, so good. It’s a bit of a gamble though, since the lime wash can react differently with various pigments.

That’s interesting about mixing pigments. I’ve stuck to the pre-mixed lime wash colors for consistency, but I’ve noticed that even those can vary a lot in durability. My south-facing wall faded within a couple of years, but the north-facing one still looks great. Maybe it’s more about exposure than the paint itself?

3 Likes

I’ve been using lime wash indoors for a while now, and I’ve found that the key to longevity is in the preparation of the wall. A well-prepared surface seems to make the lime wash adhere better and last longer. As for mixing pigments, I haven’t tried it myself, but I’ve heard that some natural pigments can actually weaken the lime wash’s natural properties.

4 Likes

I’m curious about the environmental impact of sourcing natural pigments for mixing. Does anyone know if the extraction process for these pigments is sustainable? I love the idea of enhancing color durability, but not at the expense of the environment.

1 Like

Regarding exterior applications, I’ve had mixed results with lime wash. It’s beautiful and eco-friendly, but in areas with heavy rain, it tends to wear off faster. I wonder if there’s a way to seal it without compromising its breathability and eco-friendly qualities.