Hey fellow green living enthusiasts! 
I’ve recently embarked on a journey to repaint my living room with the most eco-friendly options out there, and I’ve stumbled upon an interesting comparison: historical lime wash versus modern eco-friendly lime-based paints. I’m torn between sticking to the traditional methods our ancestors used or going for the newer, supposedly more efficient options.
I’ve tried a couple of eco-friendly paints before, like Earthborn Claypaint, which was great for its breathability and lack of VOCs, but I’m curious about lime-based options. I’ve read that historical lime wash is incredibly durable and has natural antibacterial properties, which sounds amazing. However, I’m also intrigued by modern lime-based paints like Lime Green Paint Company’s offerings, which claim to combine the best of traditional lime with modern technology for easier application and a wider range of colors.
My main question is, has anyone here used both historical lime wash and modern lime-based paints on their interior walls? How do they compare in terms of application, durability, and finish? Also, considering the environmental impact, which one do you think is more sustainable in the long run? I’m particularly interested in how they perform on older walls that might have their own set of challenges.
Looking forward to hearing your experiences and thoughts! Let’s make our homes not just beautiful, but truly green. 
Great topic, @EcoPainter88! I’ve used both historical lime wash and modern lime-based paints in my home. The historical lime wash was a bit challenging to apply, requiring multiple coats and a lot of patience. However, the finish was incredibly matte and had a unique, soft texture that really brought out the character of my old walls. On the other hand, modern lime-based paints, like those from Lime Green Paint Company, were much easier to apply and offered a wider range of colors. Durability-wise, both have held up well, but I noticed the modern paint was slightly more resistant to stains.
3 Likes
Thanks for sharing your experience, @GreenThumb99! The ease of application with modern paints is definitely appealing. Did you notice any difference in the breathability between the two? I’m particularly concerned about moisture, especially since my house is quite old.
1 Like
@EcoPainter88, both options are breathable, which is great for moisture control. However, I did find that the historical lime wash seemed to handle humidity a bit better, possibly due to its porous nature. That said, the modern lime-based paint still performed well, and I didn’t have any issues with mold or mildew.
2 Likes
I’ve only used modern lime-based paints, specifically Lime Green Paint Company’s products, and I’ve been really impressed. The application was straightforward, and the paint dried to a beautiful, even finish. I chose a light, earthy tone that really complements the natural light in my living room. As for sustainability, I appreciate that the company uses natural ingredients and has a low environmental impact. It’s a win-win for me!
4 Likes
That’s great to hear, @NatureLover23! The color range is definitely a plus for modern paints. Do you know if Lime Green Paint Company offers any finishes other than matte? I’m exploring different options to see what would work best in my space.
1 Like
@EcoPainter88, they do offer a few different finishes, including a soft sheen that adds a subtle glow to the walls without being too shiny. It’s perfect for creating a warm, inviting atmosphere. I went with the matte finish for a more natural look, but the soft sheen is beautiful too!
2 Likes
I’m a big fan of historical lime wash for its authenticity and the way it ages beautifully over time. Yes, it’s more labor-intensive, but there’s something rewarding about using a method that’s been around for centuries. Plus, the antibacterial properties are a bonus, especially in a kitchen or bathroom. That said, I understand the appeal of modern options for their convenience and color variety.
3 Likes
I love the idea of using a method with such history, @OldSoul45. The antibacterial aspect is particularly appealing. Did you find the lime wash difficult to maintain over time?
1 Like
@EcoPainter88, maintenance hasn’t been too bad. The key is to avoid harsh cleaning chemicals, as they can damage the finish. A soft cloth and mild soap are usually enough to keep it looking fresh. Over time, the lime wash develops a lovely patina that adds character to the walls.
2 Likes
I’ve dabbled with both as well, and I gotta say, the historical lime wash has this charm that modern paints just can’t replicate. Sure, it’s a bit of a pain to apply, but the end result is worth it. My walls look like they’ve got centuries of stories to tell. Modern lime-based paints are convenient, but they lack that soul, you know?
Interesting take! I’m all about the modern lime-based paints though. The ease of application and the color options are a game changer for me. Plus, I’m not the most patient person, so anything that saves me time is a win. I do wonder though, how does the environmental impact compare? Is one more sustainable than the other?
4 Likes
From an environmental standpoint, I think it’s a toss-up. Historical lime wash is all-natural, which is great, but the modern versions have made strides in reducing their carbon footprint. It really comes down to what you value more: tradition or innovation. Either way, you’re making a greener choice than going with conventional paints.
5 Likes
I’ve been curious about the antibacterial properties mentioned. Does anyone know if modern lime-based paints retain that feature? It’s something I’d love to have in my home, especially in the kitchen and bathroom areas. Also, how do these paints fare with mold resistance compared to traditional lime wash?
1 Like
I’ve dabbled with both, and honestly, it’s a tough call. Historical lime wash has this unique, matte finish that modern paints struggle to replicate. It’s like the walls have a story to tell. But, yeah, applying it can be a bit of a workout. Modern lime-based paints, on the other hand, are a breeze to apply and come in a variety of shades. If you’re after ease and color options, modern might be the way to go.
1 Like
I’m all for sticking with historical lime wash. There’s something about using a method that’s been around for centuries that feels right, especially in older homes. It’s not just paint; it’s a piece of history. Plus, the antibacterial properties are a huge bonus. Sure, it might be a bit more labor-intensive, but the results are worth it.
2 Likes
Modern lime-based paints have my vote. I used Lime Green Paint Company’s paint in my kitchen, and it’s held up incredibly well against moisture and stains. The application was straightforward, and the color options are fantastic. It’s great to have a product that’s both eco-friendly and practical for everyday living.
1 Like
I think it really depends on the look you’re going for and the condition of your walls. Historical lime wash gives a more authentic, rustic finish, which can be stunning in the right setting. But if your walls aren’t in great shape, modern lime-based paints might offer better coverage and durability. It’s all about balancing aesthetics with practicality.
4 Likes
I’ve used both, and honestly, it comes down to what you value more: tradition or convenience. Historical lime wash does have a charm and depth that modern paints can’t replicate. It’s like each layer tells a story. But, it’s true, it’s a bit of a workout to apply. Modern lime-based paints, on the other hand, are a breeze to use and you get more color options. If you’re not up for the labor, modern might be the way to go.
3 Likes
I lean towards modern eco-friendly lime-based paints for interior walls. The technology has come a long way, and these paints offer a good balance between being environmentally friendly and practical. They’re easier to apply, dry faster, and you don’t have to worry about the pH levels as much as with traditional lime wash. Plus, the color range is a big win for me. It’s hard to beat the convenience and the finish you get with modern options.