Hey fellow eco-warriors! 
I’ve been diving deep into the world of natural paints for my latest home renovation project, and I’ve narrowed it down to two contenders: milk paint and clay paint. Both seem fantastic, but I’m torn on which to choose for my living room walls. I’ve previously used a lime-based paint in my bathroom, which was great for moisture resistance, but I’m looking for something with a bit more color depth this time around.
Milk paint, from what I’ve gathered, is super eco-friendly, made from simple ingredients like milk protein, lime, and natural pigments. I’m intrigued by its historical use and the matte finish it provides. On the other hand, clay paint boasts excellent coverage and a velvety texture, plus it’s known for its ability to regulate humidity. Both sound amazing, but I’m curious about their application experiences. Has anyone here worked with either? How do they handle on different surfaces, especially older walls that might have seen better days?
I’m also keen on understanding the environmental impact of each. While both are leaps and bounds better than conventional paints, I wonder about the sourcing of ingredients and the overall sustainability of the production processes. If you’ve tried either milk or clay paint, what was your experience like? Any tips for a first-timer? Let’s share our stories and help each other make our homes a little greener! 
I’ve used both milk paint and clay paint in different rooms of my house, and each has its unique charm. Milk paint, with its historical roots, gave my dining room a rustic, antique look that I absolutely adore. The matte finish is perfect for hiding imperfections on older walls. On the other hand, clay paint in my bedroom has been a game-changer for air quality. Its ability to regulate humidity is unmatched, especially during the damp seasons. For your living room, consider the overall vibe you’re aiming for. If it’s warmth and texture, clay paint might be your best bet.
4 Likes
@EcoExplorer88 Thanks for sharing your experience! The humidity regulation aspect of clay paint is definitely appealing, especially since my living room tends to get a bit stuffy. Did you find the application process for clay paint to be straightforward? I’m a bit nervous about getting an even coat.
2 Likes
@GreenThumbJenny Absolutely! Clay paint is surprisingly forgiving. I used a roller for the walls and a brush for the edges, and it went on smoothly. The key is to apply it in thin, even layers. It dries to a beautiful, velvety finish that’s worth the effort. Plus, it’s low VOC, so no strong paint fumes to deal with!
3 Likes
I’m all for milk paint! The depth of color you can achieve is incredible, and it’s so eco-friendly. I used it in my kitchen, and it’s held up really well against moisture and stains. Plus, the fact that it’s made from natural ingredients like milk protein and lime is a huge win for the environment. If you’re concerned about sustainability, milk paint is the way to go.
5 Likes
@NatureLover101 That’s great to hear about the durability in the kitchen! I was a bit worried about how it might handle high-traffic areas. Did you use any special sealant or just the milk paint as is?
1 Like
@GreenThumbJenny I applied a natural beeswax sealant over the milk paint for extra protection, especially around the sink and stove areas. It’s been a year, and the walls still look fantastic. The sealant also enhanced the color depth, giving it a lovely sheen.
4 Likes
Has anyone compared the cost between milk paint and clay paint? I’m all for going green, but I also need to stick to a budget. Any insights would be greatly appreciated!
2 Likes
@DIYQueen From my experience, clay paint tends to be a bit more expensive upfront, but its coverage is excellent, so you might end up using less product. Milk paint is more affordable but might require additional coats or a sealant, which could add to the cost. It really depends on the size of your project and the finish you’re aiming for.
3 Likes
I’ve been a fan of milk paint for years, especially for furniture. But when it comes to walls, I lean towards clay paint. The texture it adds to a room is something else. Plus, the humidity control is a big win for me. Have you considered the color options available for each? I found that clay paint offers a wider range of modern hues, which might be something to think about for your living room.
5 Likes
Interesting take on clay paint’s humidity control. I went with milk paint for my kitchen walls and haven’t looked back. The depth of color you can achieve is stunning, and it’s held up surprisingly well against steam and splashes. But I do agree, the choice really depends on the vibe you’re going for. For a more rustic, cozy feel, milk paint is hard to beat.
3 Likes
I’m all about the eco-friendly aspect, so I did a deep dive into the sourcing of ingredients for both paints. Milk paint’s simplicity is appealing, but I was impressed by how sustainable clay paint production can be, especially when sourced locally. It’s something to consider if you’re prioritizing environmental impact. Also, the application process for clay paint was smoother in my experience, less prep work needed.
1 Like
Both paints have their merits, but I think the key is in the preparation of your walls. Older walls can be tricky, and I found that milk paint required a bit more elbow grease to get a smooth finish. Clay paint was more forgiving. Have you thought about doing a test patch? Sometimes seeing the paint in your own space, with your lighting, can make the decision clearer.
4 Likes
I’ve been using clay paint in my home for a while now, and I can’t recommend it enough. The texture is just unbeatable, and it really does help with humidity control. My living room feels so much fresher. Plus, it’s a breeze to apply, even on older walls. If you’re looking for something that’s both practical and eco-friendly, clay paint might just be your best bet.
1 Like
Milk paint sounds interesting, especially with its historical background. But I’m a bit concerned about its durability. Has anyone had issues with it chipping or fading over time? I’m all for eco-friendly options, but I also need something that’s going to last without constant touch-ups.
4 Likes
I tried both milk and clay paints in different rooms to see which I preferred. Honestly, it’s a tough call. Milk paint gave me that rich, deep color I was after, but clay paint was easier to work with and covered better. If I had to choose, I’d probably go with clay paint for its practicality, but I do miss the unique finish of milk paint.
2 Likes
For those worried about the environmental impact, it’s worth noting that both paints are significantly better than conventional options. However, the production process of milk paint might have a slight edge in sustainability, given its simpler, more natural ingredients. It’s a small difference, but every bit helps when we’re trying to reduce our footprint.
2 Likes
I’m curious about the color options available with clay paint. I’ve heard milk paint can be mixed to achieve a wide range of colors, but what about clay paint? Does it offer the same versatility, or are you more limited in your choices? I’m planning to redecorate my home office and want something that can match my vision perfectly.
2 Likes
I’ve actually used both milk paint and clay paint in different rooms of my house. When it comes to cost, milk paint was a bit more expensive upfront, but I found it went a long way because of how concentrated it is. Clay paint was cheaper per gallon, but I needed more coats to get the coverage I wanted, so it kind of evened out in the end. Both are great options, but if you’re really watching your budget, you might want to calculate the cost per square foot based on how many coats you think you’ll need.
4 Likes
Cost-wise, I went with clay paint for my project because it was more affordable for the amount I needed. I was covering a large area, and the clay paint’s coverage was decent, though I did end up doing two coats. I’ve heard milk paint can be more cost-effective for smaller projects or when you’re going for a specific historical look. It really depends on the size of your project and the look you’re going for. Also, don’t forget to factor in the cost of any primers or sealers you might need, as that can add up.