Hey everyone! 
I’m in the middle of giving my 1920s bungalow a much-needed facelift, and I’m determined to keep things as eco-friendly as possible. I’ve been diving deep into the world of natural paints, and I’m particularly intrigued by milk paint for achieving that authentic vintage look. So far, I’ve experimented with Real Milk Paint Co. on a few smaller projects, and I love the matte finish and the way it ages beautifully over time. However, I’m curious to hear about your experiences with other brands. Have any of you tried The Old Fashioned Milk Paint Company or Miss Mustard Seed’s Milk Paint? How do they compare in terms of color selection, ease of use, and environmental impact?
I’m also wondering about surface compatibility. My home has a mix of plaster walls and old wood trim. I’ve read that milk paint can be a bit finicky on certain surfaces without proper prep. Any tips or tricks you’ve learned along the way? And for those who’ve gone the extra mile, have you found any particular sealers or finishes that complement milk paint well without compromising its eco-friendly nature?
Looking forward to hearing your thoughts and recommendations. Let’s share our knowledge and help each other create beautiful, sustainable spaces! 
Hey @EcoRenovator88, I’ve had a great experience with The Old Fashioned Milk Paint Company. Their color selection is fantastic, and I find their paint to be very user-friendly. It’s perfect for achieving that vintage look you’re going for. As for surface compatibility, I’ve used it on both plaster and wood with excellent results, but proper prep is key. I always recommend a good cleaning and possibly a primer if the surface is very porous. For a sealer, I’ve used Beeswax Polish and it works wonderfully without harming the eco-friendly aspect of the paint.
3 Likes
Thanks, @GreenThumb99! I’ll definitely check out The Old Fashioned Milk Paint Company. The Beeswax Polish tip is gold. Do you find that it alters the matte finish of the milk paint at all?
1 Like
@EcoRenovator88, it does add a slight sheen, but it’s very minimal and actually enhances the vintage look in my opinion. It also adds a layer of protection which is great for high-traffic areas.
2 Likes
I’m a big fan of Miss Mustard Seed’s Milk Paint. The colors are vibrant and true to the swatches. I used it on an old dresser and the finish was exactly what I was hoping for - very authentic and vintage. One thing to note is that it can be a bit unpredictable, which I actually enjoy because it adds character to each piece. For surfaces, I agree with @GreenThumb99, prep is crucial. I’ve had the best results on raw wood.
4 Likes
@VintageSoul, the unpredictability sounds intriguing! Do you have any tips for first-time users to manage that aspect?
1 Like
@EcoRenovator88, definitely do a test patch first to see how the paint reacts with your surface. Also, mixing the paint thoroughly and letting it sit for a bit before application can help achieve a more consistent finish. But honestly, embracing the unpredictability is part of the charm!
3 Likes
Has anyone tried mixing brands of milk paint? I’m curious if combining Real Milk Paint Co. with Miss Mustard Seed’s Milk Paint could create unique colors or finishes. Or is it better to stick with one brand for consistency?
2 Likes
@NatureLover23, that’s an interesting idea! I haven’t tried mixing brands myself, but I’d be curious to hear if anyone else has. It could be a fun experiment to create custom colors.
1 Like
I’ve been using Miss Mustard Seed’s Milk Paint for a while now, and I’m really impressed with the depth of color you can achieve. It’s a bit different from Real Milk Paint Co. in terms of texture, but once you get the hang of it, the results are stunning. For old wood trim, I found that a light sanding before application helps a lot. As for sealers, I’ve been experimenting with Hemp Oil and it seems to preserve the paint’s integrity while adding a nice sheen.
2 Likes
Just chiming in to say that The Old Fashioned Milk Paint Company is my go-to as well. Their historical color palette is unmatched, and the paint mixes up really smoothly. I’ve used it on plaster walls with a bit of bonding agent mixed in, and it adheres beautifully. For a finish, I prefer Tung Oil because it’s natural and really brings out the richness of the colors.
1 Like
I tried Miss Mustard Seed’s Milk Paint on a vintage dresser and was blown away by the authentic look it gave. The key for me was the preparation; I made sure to clean and lightly sand the surface first. I didn’t use a sealer because I wanted the paint to age naturally, but I’ve heard good things about Carnauba Wax for those who want a bit of protection.
I’m a big fan of Real Milk Paint Co. for its eco-friendliness and the way it ages. I’ve used it on both wood and plaster, and while it does require some prep, the effort is worth it. I’ve been using Linseed Oil as a sealer, and it’s been great for enhancing the paint’s durability without compromising its natural look.
I’ve experimented with both The Old Fashioned Milk Paint Company and Miss Mustard Seed’s Milk Paint, and each has its strengths. For a project that required a lot of color mixing, I found Miss Mustard Seed’s to be more forgiving. On the other hand, The Old Fashioned Milk Paint Company’s colors are so rich and vibrant right out of the bag. For sealing, I’ve had success with Shellac, especially on high-traffic areas. It’s a bit more work, but the finish is durable and still keeps that vintage charm.
5 Likes
I’ve been using The Old Fashioned Milk Paint Company for a while now, and I must say, their color range is pretty impressive. It gives that perfect vintage vibe without looking too overdone. I used it on my kitchen cabinets, and the finish was exactly what I was aiming for. As for surface prep, I found that a good sanding and a coat of their bonding agent did the trick, even on surfaces that weren’t raw wood. It’s a bit of extra work, but totally worth it for the end result.
3 Likes
I tried Miss Mustard Seed’s Milk Paint on a whim for a small project, and I was pleasantly surprised. The colors are indeed vibrant, and the finish has that authentic, aged look that’s hard to achieve with modern paints. I used it on a wooden chair, and despite the unpredictability, it turned out beautifully. For those worried about the unpredictability, I think it adds to the charm, making each piece unique. As for sealers, I’ve been experimenting with natural waxes, and they seem to complement the milk paint well without detracting from its eco-friendly nature.
2 Likes
I’ve actually mixed Real Milk Paint Co. with Miss Mustard Seed’s Milk Paint on a small project, and it turned out pretty interesting. The colors blended well, but I did notice a slight difference in texture. It’s definitely worth experimenting with if you’re going for a unique look, but for larger projects, sticking to one brand might be safer for consistency.
5 Likes
Mixing brands sounds like a fun experiment, but I’d be worried about the environmental impact. Each brand has its own formula, and combining them might not be as eco-friendly as using a single brand. Plus, the prep work for different surfaces can vary, so it might complicate things more than it’s worth.
2 Likes
I haven’t mixed brands, but I’ve used both Real Milk Paint Co. and Miss Mustard Seed’s Milk Paint separately. I found Miss Mustard Seed’s to have a slightly smoother application, but Real Milk Paint Co. has a more authentic vintage look. It really depends on what you’re going for. As for sealers, I’ve had good luck with natural beeswax. It doesn’t compromise the eco-friendly aspect and adds a nice protective layer.
1 Like
That’s an interesting idea about mixing brands. I wonder if the chemical composition of each brand would react differently when mixed. It might be worth doing a small test patch to see how they interact over time. Also, considering the age of your home, have you thought about the potential for lead in the old paint layers? It’s something to be mindful of when prepping surfaces.